To help or not to help still the question

A passerby helps an old man who was hit by a car, in Beijing, Sept 9, 2014. [Photo/IC]

A student at Huainan Normal University is seeking witnesses who saw her helping an elderly resident who had fallen, after the woman's family accused her of being the cause of the old lady's fall. Comments:

In a civil lawsuit, a plaintiff who files a lawsuit against someone for being the cause of an accident needs to provide evidence to back up their accusation. Of course the judge can make a decision based on indirect evidence, but in the student's case there is no evidence to suggest she was responsible. However, the reality is in previous cases the courts simply asked the two parties to divide the responsibility if there was no evidence to show who should be held responsible. As a result, many will think twice before going to the help of senior citizens.

Beijing Times, Sept 11

In some previous cases, senior citizens have accused good Samaritans of being the cause of their accidents but were finally proved to have told a lie, yet they got away without being punished. The judges failed to perform their duty because these elderly accusers violated the law.

Beijing News, Sept 10

The family of the senior said that if Yuan did not cause the accident, why did she extend a helping hand and even help pay for the emergency medical care? This is absurd logic, as the woman didn't have enough money on her to cover the cost. Worse, such logic has been used in similar cases to extort money from a good Samaritan. That logic has already hurt enough good people.

rednet, Sept 11