Using AIDS to dodge crimes
(China Daily)
Updated: 2004-06-06 10:35

On May 26 two pickpockets were caught red-handed in Xi'an, capital city of Northwest China's Shaanxi Province. They were stealing a cellphone.

Two pickpockets are caught red-handed in Xi抋n, capital city of Northwest China's Shaanxi Province on May 26. One of them claimed he had AIDS, which reportedly left police in an "awkward" position. Police first asked the victim, surnamed Yan, together with the suspect, to go to a local police station in a taxi but Yan refused. [newsphoto]

A few minutes later two police cars arrived on the scene. The cops questioned the suspects, the taller of whom claimed he had AIDS. A piece of paper in his pocket mentioned the disease.

The cops decided to first send the short suspect back to the station and leave the other to the local emergency center.

An ambulance pulled up. The paramedics, after learning the nature of the emergency, would not even get out of the vehicle. They said only the provincial disease control center could handle such a situation, and they had no protective gear.

For a full hour there was an impasse. Finally instructions were relayed. The ambulance was ordered to transport the suspect to the police station. Before it pulled away, the paramedics insisted one of the cops sit with them. After some hesitation, the police obliged.

As a crime-fighting melodrama, this was far from a heart-pounding, tire-screeching episode. Yet, it vividly illustrates the predicament of law enforcement agents who, in the line of duty, face a deadly disease that is quietly wriggling its way through the fabric of Chinese society.

Lethal weapon

In recent years special clusters of petty crooks have emerged in urban China. When they are caught, they do not hesitate to announce they are carriers of the HIV virus. As a result, they rarely face detention.

Word seems to spread quickly among these groups. They soon find out which city has the most "lenient" police. For quite some time, Hangzhou of Zhejiang Province, known for its beautiful West Lake, was also a haven for so-called "AIDS pickpockets." Cops would rarely lay a hand on them, let alone abuse them.

Police called a local emergency center for an ambulance. The medical workers, however, would not assist on the grounds that they had no protective gear. [newsphoto]

The social stigma surrounding the country's AIDS patients is such that a few carriers of the virus, real or not, have transformed it into a protective shield while engaging in illegal activities. For a while there was even rumors that gullible youngsters in backward regions were injecting the virus into their bodies so that they could roam free in the urban underground and pick pockets with impunity.

"Who would be so stupid to do that?" retorts Lao Shu, a thief convicted in Hangzhou but originally from Luzhai County in the Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region.

Many of the "AIDS pickpockets" in this picturesque tourist town are Luzhai natives. Yet Lao does not know a single one who would want a grand career of thievery by subjecting himself to a lethal injection.

Like 61.6 per cent of the country's HIV carriers, Lao got the virus by taking drugs, "probably when sharing needles with others."

He got hooked at the tender age of 13, moved to Hangzhou at 15, and was infected with HIV the next year, in 2000. He cannot even remember how many times he has been arrested or sent to mandatory drug rehabilitation. Every time he comes out, he reverts to stealing "because that's the only way to support my drug habit."

Lao reveals that it takes him about 10 seconds to steal a wallet, usually by using a small clamp. His average daily take is 600 yuan (US$73), roughly what a migrant worker in China would make in a month. But it can support only two days of his drug consumption. He says he never resists police arrest. "I just follow them. They usually set me free in a few days and everything is back to normal."

By "normal" he means living off other's property surreptitiously and in the shadow of death. "We never bring up the topic of AIDS among ourselves," he says.

Police dilemma

Late last year, Hangzhou police rounded up members of this group. Of the 26 people arrested during the initial campaign, 13 tested positive to the AIDS virus.

After some hesitation, a policeman sits away from the suspect who claims to be an AIDS patient. [newsphoto]

To stem the tide of worsening social order and deal with mounting public complaints, police had to take action. But the cost is steep.

Wang Qingkun, a local officer, disclosed that they have a pilot programme in place for "putting AIDS pickpockets in one facility." To insure security, at least one policeman is assigned for each offender/patient. Everyone must wear two layers of gloves, a special mask and helmet. No sharp objects are allowed on the premises. Special sanitation policies are also adopted.

On top of that, there is the health-care cost. "Who will foot the bill? The department of healthcare, or justice or public security? Each person will incur an annual cost of 100,000 yuan (US$12,091)," says Wang.

Then there is the legal quandary. Many of them are incarcerated for minor misdemeanors and the judge probably would not dole out long sentences. And those who receive harsher sentences may become despondent and do something that might harm themselves or those around them.

"It is a social issue that requires co-ordination from many agencies," says the officer.

For the moment, authorities are putting a humanitarian touch on details. They persuade the media not to publish the full name, image or identity of the suspects, and keep vigilant of their state of mind. Even though the cost of trying the cases is higher, "we'll be fair in sentencing; making it either lighter or harsher is an insult to the defendants," said one court insider.

"The 'AIDS pickpockets' live on the periphery of society. They need our care, not our discrimination. By caring for them, we're also caring for ourselves," says Qin Huiqun, director of the disease control center in Luzhai, Guangxi.

Occupational hazard

If you think law enforcement agencies are over-sensitive, you need only consider the case of Du Lianyi.

Last November the 29-year-old Beijing cop was bitten on the finger by a drug dealer in a scuffle. The suspect tested positive for HIV. Du was told that the chance of catching the virus through saliva was slim and was given treatment.

In the next few months he tried to stay away from his family. When his wife finally found out the truth, she said, teary-eyed: "You should have told me."

"I wouldn't deny that the mental pressure was crumbling," Du said a few months later, still testing negative.

"In some other countries, people in my line of work are entitled to psychological counselling. I just wish the experts would come up with some methods to deal with AIDS-inflicted criminal elements.

"There's got to be a way that's both fair for them and good for the whole society."

Close

Today's Top News     Top China News
NPC weighs momentous new bankruptcy law         Asian nations vows to meet oil needs         FM sets up new branch to enhance security         Pro-independence investors not welcome         Japan-born panda cub happy back         US generals to face Abu Ghraib questioning	Thailand concedes China `market economy' status       Temple fire a warning call       Aussies restore purloined Sino dinosaur eggs       Leaning pagoda to be protected       Working group gathers for 6-party talks       Evans willing to introduce US firms to Heilongjiang